Hofstra, LIU basketball coaches earn almost as much as their college presidents. Search our database.
Craig "Speedy" Claxton coached Hofstra to its first NCAA tournament bid since 2001. Credit: Newsday/Howard Schnapp
Long Island college basketball had a banner year last season: Hofstra and Long Island University returned to the NCAA Tournament after significant droughts.
Hofstra hadn’t made a trip to March Madness since 2001. LIU last qualified in 2018, but was just three years removed from being one of the worst teams in the nation.
The two private, nonprofit schools hired local basketball legends Craig "Speedy" Claxton and Rod Strickland as their respective head coaches with this precise aim, hoping to boost enrollment and rebuild their brands in the process.
The costs, however, are annual compensation packages totaling more than $800,000 each — the most in Hofstra and LIU’s athletic conferences and nearly as much as the schools’ presidents, a Newsday analysis of public records show.
WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND
- Long Island nonprofit schools employed 33,000 people and reported over $3 billion in revenue, IRS filings shows.
- Head basketball coaches at Hofstra and Long Island University were the second-highest-paid employees at their schools.
- Hofstra's Craig "Speedy" Claxton and LIU's Rod Strickland made more than any other basketball coaches in their respective conferences.
As schools grapple with declining enrollment and academic cuts, federal tax filings reveal the escalating cost of seeking athletic prestige. When painful decisions must be made elsewhere, how much are they willing to pay to win?
The nation’s premier Division I basketball programs have long paid their head coaches at levels at or above top administrators, but certain mid-major schools are now doing the same.
While the universities say the spending benefits the institution at large, sports economists and experts are skeptical. Schools tend to spend more than they earn from basketball, the economists and experts said, especially in the case of smaller market schools that don’t fill large arenas or appear often on national television.
"More often than not, it’s not a good investment," said Andrew Zimbalist, Robert A. Woods professor emeritus of economics at Smith College, who specializes in the field of pay in college athletics.
Outside factors such as inflation and impact from federal policies, such as immigration, he said, "are making it difficult for colleges to survive, and they’re inducing cuts in all sorts of areas."
Hofstra, despite the tournament bid, is proposing budget cuts, with professors this month giving its president a vote of no confidence. The school's board of trustees rejected the vote as "groundless."
But supporters of paying coaches as key figures in a school's ecosystem say there is much more to consider.
Craig Robinson, executive director of the National Association of Basketball Coaches, which advocates for college coaches, said these compensation packages reflect a "wide range of responsibilities and impact on the institution."
"The demands placed on college basketball coaches to effectively manage every facet of their programs — from in-game strategy and recruiting to modern roster construction and budget allocation — have never been greater," Robinson said in a statement, adding coaches are among "the most influential public ambassadors of their universities."
The increase in pay for college basketball coaches is just one section of a Long Island nonprofit school industry, including private universities, elite boarding schools and specialized education, that reported to the federal government $3 billion in revenue as it employed 33,000 people and paid $82 million in compensation to its top employees.
Newsday is examining pay to nonprofit leaders through a first-of-its-kind compilation of nonprofits headquartered on Long Island, using each tax-exempt organization’s most recent filing to the IRS by the end of 2025. Last month, it highlighted that more than 130 people earned at least $1 million annually from their nonprofits, with almost all of them working in healthcare.
The information — provided in a searchable database by name, organization and location — offers the public a unique tool to understand compensation in a major employment sector of Nassau and Suffolk counties that is excluded from paying certain taxes.
In the database running with this story, Newsday highlights educational nonprofits, including private colleges and K-12 schools. Many religious schools, particularly Catholic, are excluded from the data because they are not required to submit filings to the IRS.
The data doesn't disclose how schools fund their compensation packages or, in the cases of the college coaches, whether their pay directly contributed to cuts elsewhere at the institution.
A ‘Speedy’ rise

Hofstra fell to Alabama in last spring's NCAA Tournament. Credit: Getty Images/Mike Carlson
Claxton, a Hempstead native and Hofstra graduate, was hired as head coach in 2021 after several years as an assistant. The Pride’s conference championship last season led to an automatic bid into the tournament, where the team lost in its first game to No. 4 seed Alabama.
"Hopefully it’ll boost enrollment," Claxton said in March as they celebrated their March Madness berth. "It’ll give some notoriety to the university."
Hofstra paid Claxton $469,000 in 2022-23, about as much as the coach he replaced and less than half the pay of university President Susan Poser.
The following year, as reflected in Newsday’s database, his pay bumped up to nearly $800,000 with an additional $115,000 in nontaxable benefits, such as insurance, according to the university’s tax filing.
Last year, Claxton, who played nine seasons in the NBA, made over $1 million from Hofstra as his pay increased to $985,000 — including a $110,000 bonus — with an additional $134,000 in nontaxable benefits.
Poser made about $1.3 million — plus nearly $62,000 in retirement, deferred compensation and nontaxable benefits — during the last IRS reporting period, records show. The prior year, which is reflected in Newsday’s database, she earned slightly less in total compensation.
That year, Poser ranked behind only college Presidents Kimberly Cline, of LIU — who made about $2 million, plus $309,000 in additional pay and benefits — and Henry Foley, of New York Institute of Technology — almost $1.3 million, plus $47,000 in other compensation — in Newsday’s analysis of IRS data.
Newsday requested interviews with Claxton or Hofstra’s athletic director and a representative of its board of trustees to discuss coach compensation issues. It also requested a copy of the school's financial statements submitted to the NCAA, which public schools generally provide upon request.
The school didn't provide the interviews or financial statements, but Hofstra spokesperson Terry Coniglio said in a statement: "Coach Claxton’s compensation is drawn from both athletics funds as well as the university budget."
More pay than conference rivals
Claxton’s compensation is just above that of the recently departed coach of fellow Coastal Athletic Conference member College of Charleston, which paid Chris Mack $1 million, according to a filing submitted to the NCAA.
Geno Ford, men's basketball coach at Stony Brook University — which is also in Hofstra's conference — received $790,000 in total compensation, according to filings obtained by Extra Points, a college sports news outlet run by journalist and researcher Matt Brown. The university paid him $486,000 with the remainder covered by the state in fringe benefits, a spokesman said.

Stony Brook men's basketball coach Geno Ford received $790,000 in total compensation. Credit: Jess Rapfogel
Stony Brook is not part of Newsday’s database because it is a public state university, not a private nonprofit.
Detailed revenue and expenses are not available for private schools like Hofstra, but Stony Brook’s finances provide a glimpse into the difficulties of smaller programs profiting from athletics.
The university reported a $4 million loss from sports in 2024-25, despite generating $11 million in student fees, according to the public records obtained by Extra Points, with men’s basketball accounting for $1.3 million.
Asked about Ford's pay compared with revenue from school athletics, Stony Brook athletic director Shawn Heilbron said "the investment in athletics at Stony Brook is immeasurable."
"Our role is to carry the banner for our institution nationally and regionally while creating unique opportunities to engage our campus and community," Heilbron said in a statement to Newsday. "Fundraising and other revenue-generating activities have thrived in recent years thanks in large part to the increasing visibility of our athletics program."
Hofstra reported to the U.S. Department of Education that it spent $4.3 million to run its men’s basketball program in roughly the 2024-25 school year. Its spending grew by 70% over the last decade and has nearly tripled over the last 20 years.
"College presidents and ADs follow along with the momentum in the system," Zimbalist said of the trend of increased athletics spending and salaries. "If they follow along with the momentum, they won’t be awarded and applauded for success, but at least they won’t be singled out for not doing what everybody else is doing."
‘Strengthens' reputation

LIU lost to Arizona in the first round of last spring's tournament. Credit: The San Diego Union-Tribune via /The San Diego Union-Tribune
Like Hofstra, the LIU Sharks in recent years have seen significant growth in program spending.
The school in roughly the 2024-25 academic year reported $3.5 million in men’s basketball revenue to the federal government — more than eight times what it was two decades prior.
Most of that growth has come since 2018. The school merged its Brooklyn and LIU Post campuses into one athletics department in 2019. Though the Sharks play in Brooklyn, the school retains a main headquarters in Brookville, Nassau County.
Head coach Rod Strickland, who played 17 seasons in the NBA, was hired by LIU in 2022 and made more than $751,000, plus $67,000 in retirement, other deferred compensation and nontaxable benefits, according to the most recent tax filing from the private nonprofit university. Cline, the university president, made $1.2 million, with about $311,000 in additional pay and benefits.
The database reflects Strickland’s compensation from the year prior, $650,000.
Strickland’s pay is far and above his peers in the Northeast Conference. Patrick Sellers, coach for Central Connecticut State University, the conference runner-up, earned $230,000, public records show.
"The program’s success elevates LIU’s national profile, strengthens the University’s reputation, and enriches the overall student experience," Katherine Heaviside, an LIU spokesperson, said in a statement.
The tournament appearance, she said, reflects the "strength and momentum of our basketball program." LIU did not provide details on how its board determined Strickland's pay.
Heaviside added the university "does not comment on individual personnel matters or compensation decisions."
Brown, the journalist who runs Extra Points, said his research has shown him that men’s basketball programs rarely make money for all they spend. Most public schools in the conferences of Hofstra and LIU report deficits from the programs.
He acknowledged high-profile coaches can build name recognition and serve as branding for the university. Top examples of that in the state include St. John's University coach Rick Pitino, who earns over $3.2 million, or Adrian Autry, the former basketball coach at Syracuse University, who made $2.1 million.
But in terms of measurable returns: "You could have the coach for free, and it’s not worth it."