How these 4 Latino neighborhoods played a big role in Hochul's victory on Long Island

Erika Castro of Brentwood, posing for a portrait on Nov. 13, voted for Kathy Hochul in the midterm elections. Credit: Newsday/Alejandra Villa Loarca
This story was reported by Bart Jones, Arielle Martinez, Josh Solomon and Bahar Ostadan. It was written by Ostadan.
When Erika Castro woke up last week to see immigration agents across the street from her North Bay Shore home, it was a vivid reminder of why she voted to reelect Gov. Kathy Hochul.
Latinos’ "biggest fear every day is waking up and having that knock on the door," she said. "I know firsthand the hurt ... the devastation, the separation of families."
Castro, 37, whose parents emigrated from El Salvador, was among several North Bay Shore and Brentwood residents who told Newsday that frustration with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement drove them to the polls for Hochul on Nov. 3.
Democrats in several of Long Island’s largely Latino election districts more than doubled their turnout from the last governor’s race in 2022, a Newsday analysis found, largely in response to ICE crackdowns. Their participation was significant: Without the higher turnout in Brentwood, Central Islip and North Bay Shore, Hochul might have lost Suffolk County to Republican Bruce Blakeman.
And just as she might have lost Suffolk without those communities, she might have lost Nassau without New Cassel.
In 2022, Republican gubernatorial candidate Lee Zeldin won Suffolk County by nearly 95,000 votes. This year, Hochul won by about 4,000 votes, according to election data analyzed by Newsday.
That countywide vote margin can be explained simply by Brentwood, Central Islip and North Bay Shore: Hochul more than doubled her margin of victory in those communities from four years prior as turnout soared.
Data shows 8,229 Brentwood residents voted for Hochul this year, a 70% increase from 2022, when 4,838 people voted for her. Blakeman received 1,946 votes in Brentwood, 27% less than what Zeldin got in 2022.
In Nassau's New Cassel, where two-thirds of residents are Latino, Hochul picked up 983 more votes than she did four years ago. She won the county by 913 votes.
That sleeping giant has been awoken.
— Ahmad Perez, Islip Forward founder
In Inwood, where more than 50% of residents are Latino, Hochul went from losing by 52 votes in 2022 to winning by 358 this year.
Ahmad Perez, founder of the immigration advocacy group Islip Forward, said voter turnout in Brentwood is typically low. But this year, 1 in 3 voters went to the polls, Newsday found.
"That sleeping giant has been awoken," Perez said.
Phil Ramos, deputy speaker of the Assembly, who moved to Brentwood with his family when he was 6, said it was the ICE crackdown that reunited Latinos who supported Trump in 2024 with Democrats.
"Those people who supported that MAGA movement in the beginning are seeing how it backfired on them," he previously told Newsday.
Pollsters Newsday spoke with zeroed in on areas like Brentwood, which until now had doubled its support for President Donald Trump over the last three presidential elections. Latinos nationally were key to Trump’s success in 2024. In a record for a Republican candidate, he won about half of young Latino men across the country. But almost two years into what he dubbed the largest deportation campaign in U.S. history, the tide has turned.
Castro said, "We can all agree that there are laws that must be followed ... but the aggressiveness and the targeting of Latinos is just not the way to do it."
‘Demonization of a people’
Eli Tricoche describes himself as a moderate Democrat who isn’t opposed to voting for Republicans — and sometimes has.
But when he saw Trump’s mass deportation campaign tearing apart his hometown of Brentwood, the most heavily Latino community in New York State, he said he had no doubt he was voting for Hochul. Something tore at his heart this year, replacing his usual weighing of pros and cons, he said.
Tricoche recalled his eyes filling with tears as a neighbor who had lived in the United States for about 20 years debated whether to voluntarily self-deport — and leave behind his wife and U.S.-born son — because he figured ICE agents would eventually find him.
While Tricoche, a 47-year-old of Puerto Rican descent, said he is in favor of secure borders and a pathway to legal status for undocumented immigrants, "one thing I'm definitely not for is the demonization of a people."

Eli Tricoche, of Brentwood, a social worker in the Patchogue-Medford school district, at a rally in March 2024. Credit: Rick Kopstein
"That's what I feel like we saw in the second Trump presidency in these first two years. We saw a demonization of the Latino immigrant people here in America. And that really disturbed me," he said.
Businesses that were thriving before the second Trump presidency were now shuttered, Tricoche told Newsday, adding, "My mother would talk about how folks weren't going to church. They were kind of in hiding."
Even his son had to deal with ICE agents patrolling outside the public high school in Brentwood, he said.
"This community is a beautiful community of hardworking people," Tricoche continued. "It was just tough to see ... ICE in this neighborhood, folks living in fear, reverting to the shadows. ... That, to me, was gut-wrenching."
The day after the election, Trump's new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, formerly the architect of his deportation campaign, said, "Deportations will continue," adding that ICE would take no days off including Thanksgiving and Christmas.
In New York’s suburbs, 53% of residents believe ICE tactics have "gone too far," according to an August Siena University poll. But among Latinos, that number is 72% nationally.
Election data shows that Hochul’s win wasn’t driven by scores of Brentwood’s Latino voters flipping from red to blue (most of Brentwood saw increases in the number of registered voters with no party affiliation), but rather residents who had sat out past elections voting in large numbers this time around.
"Voters in those communities came out as if their lives depended on it, which literally they did," Suffolk County Democratic Party chairman Rich Schaffer told Newsday after Election Day.
More than ICE
But immigration wasn’t the sole issue persuading Latino voters to vote blue on Election Day. Elizabeth Mercado, of Brentwood, said Hochul’s stance on issues like raising the minimum wage also drove her to the polls.
"For me, it comes down to the things that affect our families and communities every day," she said.
Sergio Argueta, an assistant principal at a Hempstead school, agreed. "Affordability is everybody’s issue," he said. "How is it that you have a household with $200,000 and you're still living paycheck to paycheck? If that’s happening to us, can you imagine the blue-collar workers that work hard every day?"
The people who came out to vote don’t even prescribe to party affiliation. They’re just looking for relief.
— Sergio Argueta, Hempstead school assistant principal
Argueta warned that despite Democrats’ success in communities like Brentwood and Hempstead, local party leaders can’t ride on the coattails of Trump’s tarnished image for long.
"The people who came out to vote don’t even prescribe to party affiliation. They’re just looking for relief," Argueta said.
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game
Loading video…
Tackling cleaner drinking water in Nassau ... MTA eying fare hikes ... Big changes at Green Acres Mall ... Previewing Jets/Chargers game



