Oheka Castle in Huntington was sold at auction last month...

Oheka Castle in Huntington was sold at auction last month for $72 million. Credit: Newsday/J. Conrad Williams Jr.

A Central Islip federal bankruptcy court judge on Tuesday signed off on the $72 million sale of Oheka Castle to a development group formed recently to purchase and manage the Huntington estate.

Judge Louis A. Scarcella, at the end of a 2½-hour hearing, approved the sale to Gold Coast Property & Estate Management LLC, headed by principals Ronald Browning and Paul Alflen.

Closing is expected in about 30 days.

Scarcella, before approving the sale, expressed concern that the buyers appeared to be struggling to meet the financial terms of the transaction.

WHAT NEWSDAY FOUND

  • A federal bankruptcy court judge approved the $72 million sale of Oheka Castle to  development group Gold Coast Property & Estate Management LLC.
  • The judge signed off on the deal after granting Gold Coast a second extension to complete required payments associated with the purchase.
  • Gold Coast had submitted the only bid during an Oct. 27 auction for the castle, its hotel and catering operations, and condominium development rights on the property.

The judge signed off on the deal after granting Gold Coast a second extension to complete required payments associated with the purchase.

Scarcella last month had granted an extension so that Gold Coast could complete paying a $7.2 million down payment. Gold Coast had failed to meet an initial Oct. 29 deadline to make that payment, which, Alflen later told Newsday, was made by the extended deadline of Nov. 6. 

Scarcella approved the second extension Tuesday, giving Gold Coast until early next month to make a separate $4.3 million payment called a "buyer's premium" to Oheka's owners and the brokers who facilitated the sale.  

Questions over extensions

The extension requests raised questions about the company's ability to manage the estate, the judge said.

"I find it puzzling, how did Gold Coast become a qualified bidder?" Scarcella said in remarks from the bench.

Steven Smith, a lawyer for lender 135 W. Gate Drive LLC, which is owed about $60 million by castle owner Kahn Property Owner LLC, implored the judge to reject Gold Coast's latest extension request.

"In the words of Yogi Berra, 'It's deja vu all over again,'" Smith said in court.

Brian Gardner, a lawyer for Gold Coast, said his clients reneged on the buyer's premium payment because they might need the money for other expenses such as meeting payroll.

The buyer's premium includes $2.8 million for auctioneers Concierge Auctions and other brokers, and $1.44 million for Oheka operator Gary Melius, said Joseph S. Maniscalco, Melius' lawyer. Melius has an ownership stake in Kahn Property Owner.

Gold Coast had submitted the only bid during an Oct. 27 auction in Manhattan for the castle, its hotel and catering operations, and condominium development rights on the property. Newsday reported previously that 135 W. Gate Drive also made a bid, offering $60 million for just the property.

The castle's sale will help Kahn Property Owner LLC pay off more than $60 million in debt.

Kahn Property Owner filed for federal Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection last year to hold off a foreclosure sale. Melius said at the time the castle had been in foreclosure for a decade.

Eyeing castle's future

After the hearing, Melius, who lives at the castle, said he was relieved by the sale, adding the process of selling it had been "tiring."

"I feel great," he said, adding he expected the castle to remain "exactly as it is" under its new owners. He said he hoped to continue living there.

Alflen said after the hearing that he and Browning plan to operate the castle much as Melius has, with weddings and other events, along with the hotel and catering facility.

The new buyers also hold the rights to build up to 95 condos in a single four-story building at the estate.

Separately, Woodbury-based Tabone LLC has filed court papers claiming it is owed $3 million by Kahn Property Owner and Melius for consulting services, Newsday previously reported. Maniscalco has objected to Tabone's claim.

A hearing on that matter is scheduled for 10 a.m. Thursday in federal bankruptcy court.

U.S. loses its measles-free status ... October's LI home prices are out ... Holiday gift guide Credit: Newsday

Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends

U.S. loses its measles-free status ... October's LI home prices are out ... Holiday gift guide Credit: Newsday

Two LI men convicted in murder of teacher ... U.S. loses its measles-free status ... Town, city healthcare costs rise ... Working Moms: Making friends

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME