A 100-year-old zoning case still shapes Long Island's health
The rate of emergency room visits for asthma is more than seven times higher in the Village of Hempstead, whose downtown is seen above in 2020, than right across the village line in Garden City. Credit: Yeong-Ung Yang
This guest essay reflects the views of Martine Hackett, chair of Hofstra University's Department of Population Health and author of "Drawing Boundaries: The Hidden Story of Suburban Public Health," forthcoming in 2027.
On a main road in an unassuming suburb of Cleveland, next to a police mini station, stands a brown Ohio historical marker. When I visited, drivers passed it without a glance. It marks the land behind a Supreme Court decision from 100 years ago that shaped the suburbs as we know them today.
The Ambler Realty Co. owned 68 acres there and planned to develop the land for industry. The Village of Euclid had adopted a zoning code to restrict the land for residential use and Ambler sued. On Nov. 22, 1926, the high court ruled that local governments could regulate what gets built on private land to protect public health, safety and the general welfare from potential hazards. Separating how land could be used became the blueprint for suburban America, and is now known as Euclidean zoning.
The court's reasoning will sound familiar to anyone who has sat through a Long Island town board hearing. Justice George Sutherland called apartment buildings "a mere parasite" and blamed them for traffic noise, streets crowded with parked cars, and "depriving children of the privilege of quiet and open spaces for play." Today the proposal might be for affordable housing, a mosque or battery storage site, but the objections are the same.
The basic framework of zoning laws has changed little since 1926, and zoning remains the most powerful tool suburban governments have to decide what gets built and where. But a century later, zoning has drifted from protecting the public and now creates health problems of its own.
These harms do not fall evenly. In my research, I have mapped health outcomes across Long Island. The rate of emergency room visits for asthma is more than seven times higher in the Village of Hempstead than right across the village line in Garden City. That is not a coincidence. Nationally, communities that are majority people of color and low income sit closer to sources of pollution and breathe more of it that trigger severe asthma attacks which bring people to ERs.
Garden City's zoning decisions that support large lots and limits on apartments have kept it quiet and protected from harm. The denser housing, busy commercial corridors and heavy traffic it kept out had to go somewhere, and much of it landed next door. As a result, the Village of Hempstead is impacted by the cumulative environmental and health burdens.
New York now has a rule that can help address the health impacts of Euclidean zoning. In June, amendments to the state's environmental review regulations, known as SEQRA, took effect.
Local planning boards are now legally required to look beyond the property line and consider if land use projects will cause or increase environmental and health burdens on a nearby designated disadvantaged community (DAC). This includes assessing if the new project will have indirect effects on the community such as increased diesel truck traffic, localized air emissions, runoff, noise or odors.
The state already lists many Village of Hempstead census tracts as DACs. Residents and community groups there and in designated communities across Long Island now have stronger legal protections in zoning and permitting decisions and can challenge projects that may disproportionately affect them.
That keeps the promise made in 1926 that zoning should protect public health, by counting the whole public. A century after Euclid, our suburbs can continue developing with everyone's health in view.
This guest essay reflects the views of Martine Hackett, chair of Hofstra University's Department of Population Health and author of "Drawing Boundaries: The Hidden Story of Suburban Public Health," forthcoming in 2027.