Erin Maloney of Franklin Square kayaks in the middle of...

Erin Maloney of Franklin Square kayaks in the middle of Woodcleft Avenue in Freeport in a flood in September. Credit: Debbie Egan-Chin

This guest essay reflects the views of Brian Shearer, the director of competition and regulatory policy at the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator, who previously worked at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

In October, anonymous industry whistleblowers in the United Kingdom and Europe raised the alarm about the economic risks of global property insurers' slow response to climate change. They accused insurers of raising profit margins at policyholders' expense — hiking prices, cutting some hazard coverage, and exiting risky areas entirely — when they should be making their businesses more efficient amid extreme weather.

While this warning came from abroad, the landscape in the United States is no better.

Like their international peers, in the face of extreme weather, U.S. insurers are increasing prices to pay for investor returns, cutting coverage and canceling policies. This in turn forces many people onto more expensive and less generous taxpayer-backed last-resort plans, or leaves them unprotected.

You might be surprised to learn which states are getting squeezed the most. From 2020-24, six of the seven states with the biggest profit margins among 10 insurance companies measured were all in the Northeast: Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Rhode Island and New York. Nationwide, the average loss ratio is 64%: $0.64 per dollar of premium goes to pay claims. That's too low. In health insurance, between $0.80 and $0.90 of premiums go to claims. But across New England and New York, the payout ratio for property insurance is below $0.50.

Every Northeastern policyholder should be outraged, not just because insurers are banking an unholy percentage of premiums, but because their policies are being used as a sort of piggy bank. Bigger margins in the Northeast allows national insurers to achieve their profit dreams without gouging other parts of the country as much as you.

We all know changing weather is raising insured losses. In theory, insurers should be preparing by tightening their belts, shaving profit margins and building reserves for future disasters.

But they aren't. In recent years property insurance profits have soared, doubling from 2022 to 2023, then doubling again to over $167 billion in 2024. They stayed high in 2025, and look to be going even higher this year.

The rainy-day fund has barely grown in line with the investment markets. So where's all their cash going? They're paying investors.

And they're wasting money, not tightening their belts. By my tally, the top 10 U.S. property insurers collectively own at least 16 corporate jets. Executive compensation is up. Insurers spend over $150 billion on ads and agent commissions every year to attract new customers. This is why you can't watch a football game without seeing insurance ads.

U.S. insurers couldn't be clearer: They're going to keep taking more of our money and spending it on ads, jets, investors and execs until state regulators stop them.

They can. State insurance regulators already have the authority and responsibility to reject prices that are excessive. States can strengthen those laws to add a requirement to give customers refunds when the margins exceed a reasonable level, like exists for health insurance nationwide. Regulators can scrutinize premiums and insist on reductions to profits, private jet spending and executive compensation. And they should require insurers to match premiums to actual risk in the state — not to subsidize other higher-risk states.

As the federal government threatens to abdicate responsibility in disaster response, state regulators and legislatures are uniquely positioned to lower costs, improve housing affordability and protect residents from unfair insurance practices. If Northeastern states act together, they'd be even stronger — especially across a region as wealthy as a midsized nation, with some of the most profitable homeowners insurance markets in the country.

This guest essay reflects the views of Brian Shearer, the director of competition and regulatory policy at the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator, who previously worked at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME