Huntington Town Supervisor Ed Smyth, center, and board members managed to...

Huntington Town Supervisor Ed Smyth, center, and board members managed to avoid a budget increase above the town's 2.68% state-imposed cap. Credit: Newsday / Steve Pfost

On Tuesday the Huntington Town Board avoided having to go ahead with an unpopular plan to pierce the state tax cap and increase taxes by 18.4%. According to town officials the increase would have meant an average of $25 more a month on residents' tax bills, or $300 per year.

In last minute maneuvering to quell the revolt, town leaders averted a budget increase above its 2.68% state-imposed cap. Councilwoman Theresa Mari introduced more than three dozen amendments projected to provide sufficient savings for the year without dismissing employees or cutting services.

The tax tension that led up to Tuesday's vote exposes the mounting fiscal pressures on municipal governments across Long Island. Nondiscretionary expenses — ranging from pensions and salaries to fuel costs — will keep escalating over the long term.

And a big part of that fiscal pressure, as Newsday's news division reported this week, stems from covering healthcare for current and retired public employees.

In a letter released recently, Huntington Supervisor Ed Smyth noted how it gets more difficult each year to "manage the tax cap, absorb health insurance costs, and meet all of the mandates coming down from Albany."

Towns and cities in Nassau and Suffolk counties spent more than $344 million on those healthcare premiums in 2025. That's up about 3% over 2024 and 37% over 2021, according to Newsday's data analysis. In some jurisdictions, these benefits can account for more than 15% of the spending plans.

There is little sign that affected localities are negotiating to pare levels of coverage for present, future or past employees. Understandably, officials are loath to do that. But the plans local governments put together next year will need to show such potentially painful considerations.

The state could help out by increasing direct aid to towns, villages and cities, and counties could help localities with a small share of their sales taxes. When the pension system's less expensive Tier 6 was sweetened for employees, the state government was expected to pick up added costs to localities. State lawmakers chose not to do that. In the budget that will be enacted in 2027, Albany could make good on that support.

But no such assistance would exempt local leaders from making difficult choices. Job vacancies can be left unfilled, as Huntington has planned. Any upcoming labor contracts will require skillful negotiations by elected officials to slow the cost of benefits.

Government needs to become more affordable for those paying the bills while continuing to maintain and improve services. Taxpayers are exhausted. Long Island budget makers need more disciplined pension changes and more direct aid from Albany while restraining their own healthcare spending.

MEMBERS OF THE EDITORIAL BOARD are experienced journalists who offer reasoned opinions, based on facts, to encourage informed debate about the issues facing our community.