Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred speaks during a news...

Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred speaks during a news conference on Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026, in NYC. Credit: AP/Ron Blum

Rob Manfred’s hawkish stance regarding a salary cap and floor at the conclusion of the MLB owners' meetings on Wednesday was the headline-grabbing portion of the commissioner’s presentation. But Manfred’s lieutenants came armed with plenty of data, too.

Knowing this upheaval of baseball’s economic system is going to be a hard sell, and currently a non-starter with the players’ union, MLB launched its most comprehensive PR assault with two weeks left before the CBA expires on Dec. 1 at 11:59 p.m. Their numbers were compelling.

— Based on 2026 payroll and luxury tax payouts, the disparity between MLB’s top spender, the Dodgers, and the club at the bottom, the Guardians, was $448 million.

— During the five years of this soon-to-expire basic agreement, which was ratified in 2022, the top four clubs — the Dodgers, Mets, Yankees and Phillies — paid a combined $5.954 billion of the free-agent contracts. The bottom 22 accounted for $5.408 billion.

— Players with zero to six years of MLB service time, essentially before becoming eligible for free agency, accounted for 71% of the WAR production yet received only 31% of the payroll compensation.

— Under the 2028 projected cap ($258.2 million) and floor ($180.2 million) proposal, eight teams (based on 2026 data) would have to decrease their payrolls by a total of $528 million to comply with the cap. At the other end, 12 clubs would need to collectively spend another $636 million to reach the floor.

— And perhaps the statistic that has riled up people the most, MLB’s survey claims that 79% of “avid” MLB fans support a salary cap (10% oppose, 11% don’t know) and 69% of “casual” MLB fans approve the idea (8% oppose, 23% don’t know).

Manfred prefers to substitute the term “competitive balance” for “salary cap” when looping the fans into his case, but those figures could be open to interpretation.

Here in New York, where the Mets and Yankees routinely land among the top three payrolls in the sport — way beyond those cap parameters — fans of both teams logically would prefer to see their financial advantages remain intact. Same for L.A., Philadelphia, Toronto, San Diego, Boston and Chicago.

But what about Miami, Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati and Colorado?

Roughly half of the league’s fan bases have pleaded with their owners for years to spend more, only to be rebuffed every winter. Forcing them to do so seems like the obvious course of action, but that’s going to be possible only if a cap also is included, cutting down the costs for large-revenue clubs, who will be giving up their bigger TV dollars to be distributed as part of the new broadcasting pie, split equally between all 30 clubs.

It’s all part of the plan. As regional networks have collapsed around the country, MLB has steadily absorbed an increasing number of game production duties and is aiming to offer the entire 30-team package when the current deals expire at the end of the 2028 season.

Manfred needs the cap-and-floor system to get everybody on board, but given that the entire concept has been radioactive to the players’ side for nearly a half-century, bargaining for it this time around feels almost impossible.

Manfred believes, however, that the sport’s recent momentum, which includes steady increases in attendance and TV ratings, is something to capitalize on with bold strokes at a pivotal time.

“I think that momentum in a business is a really important dynamic,” Manfred said. “You get that positive buzz going, it does a lot for you. I think the fastest way to lose your momentum is to do two things: stand still and stop listening to your customers. We don’t intend to stand still. We intend to continue to push for change. And we intend to continue to base our desire for change on what our fans are telling us.”

When it comes to on-field innovation, Manfred has been on a bit of a winning streak. The pitch clock — long opposed by the players' union — turned out to be an overwhelming success. Same with eliminating shifts, and more recently, the ABS review system. (We’d also add the automatic runner for extra-inning games, but there seems to be a hardcore faction of traditional fans that insists otherwise.)

The salary cap-and-floor proposal, however, is next level. Manfred did plenty of saber-rattling during Wednesday’s media session, saying he “can’t imagine the owners ratifying a deal that does not include a cap and floor.” On the flip side, those on the union side can’t possibly fathom a scenario in which the players accept such a system.

“I think the emboldenment of players and the reasons for it have never been more clear,” said agent Scott Boras, who negotiated Juan Soto’s $765 million contract two years ago and currently is working on a record-setting deal for Tarik Skubal, who is looking to establish a new bar for starting pitchers. “Players are looking at just simple facts of the success of our game. I’ve been through eight or nine of these things. Never before have we had more evidence of the true basis of what the contribution players have made to the game. Players have brought nations to our league. We have 150, 200 million more eyeballs connected to the daily observation of our game.

“That kind of evidence was not present before. So anyone who wants to, in any way, stop that momentum, I don’t know the factual basis for it.”

With the lockout clock ticking, negotiations have continued. On Friday, during the latest bargaining session, MLB dropped its proposal that sought to exclude high school players from the domestic draft. While that was portrayed as a concession to the union, MLB did stand firm on its desire for an international draft, something that the players oppose. Instead, the union proposed clear penalties for violations involving international signings and an increase in bonus pools for those prospects.

Regardless of the give-and-take in the margins, it’s difficult to glean any progress from these negotiations as long as the owners stay committed to their cap-and-floor plan for the sport. If Manfred is true to his word, there won’t be any more games without it, and as far as the 2027 season is concerned, that's pretty ominous.

“I know there’s a lot of rhetoric out there that characterizes this [salary cap] as not serious,” Manfred said. “It’s serious.”

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME