Dry Tortugas National Park is free to enter and visitors...

Dry Tortugas National Park is free to enter and visitors can swim alongside its coral-rich moat and explore marine life in clear tropical waters. Credit: Fort Jefferson Ferry via Visit Florida

Florida is a state of many islands, some bustling, some serene.

There are "a lot of islands and they are not all the same," said Bryan Griffin, president of the tourism site Visit Florida.

"You can walk a driftwood beach near Jacksonville one day ... and be on the remote coral reefs of Dry Tortugas National Park in the same week," he said. "What people like is the variety."

From the laid-back vibes of Key West to sport fishing in Islamorada, here are islands to explore in Florida.

Key West

How to get there: Fly into Miami (multiple flights on most major airlines out of LaGuardia or Kennedy) and rent a car for the 160-mile drive on the Overseas Highway. Or you can get a quick connecting flight from Miami to Key West International Airport.

Visitors explore the Hemingway Home and Museum in Key West.

Visitors explore the Hemingway Home and Museum in Key West. Credit: Florida Keys News Bureau via Visit Florida/Rob O'Neal

When you think about Key West, it’s the laid-back atmosphere that comes to mind. But the southernmost city in the United States also has an interesting history. Ernest Hemingway lived there from 1931 to 1939 — it’s where he wrote the novel "To Have and Have Not," which is set largely in Key West. 

One of the polydactyl cats at Hemingway House in Florida.

One of the polydactyl cats at Hemingway House in Florida. Credit: Visit Florida/Andy Newman

His Spanish Colonial home is now a museum, where visitors delight in spotting one of the polydactyl (six-toed) cats that descend from his famed white cat. Also on the island, Harry Truman used a former naval officer's home as his winter White House, now a museum.

Visitors in Key West ride the Conch Tour Train as...

Visitors in Key West ride the Conch Tour Train as it passes in front of Sloppy Joe's Bar, former watering hole of author Ernest Hemingway. Credit: Florida Keys News Bureau via Visit Florida/Bob Krist

A popular cruise port, the downtown area bustles with shops and restaurants (key Key lime pie is a necessity). If time is tight, you can hop aboard the Conch Train (conchtourtrain.com) for a quick tour. The main drag is Duval Street where you’ll find charming old-town architecture (lots of pastels) and hot spots like Sloppy Joe’s Bar. As the sun sets, visitors head to the nightly celebration at Mallory Square for the carnival atmosphere and views.

Ride the ferry to Dry Tortugas National Park and walk...

Ride the ferry to Dry Tortugas National Park and walk the grounds of Fort Jefferson. Credit: Fort Jefferson Ferry via Visit Florida

Key West isn’t known for its beaches, but no worries. Take the Yankee Freedom ferry (about a 2 ½-hour ride) or a seaplane (the only ways to get there) to Dry Tortugas National Park, 70 miles west. Explore the historic Fort Jefferson and snorkel or scuba the clear waters, where you’ll find plenty of fish and several shipwrecks. Hotel accommodations run from charming guesthouses to sprawling resorts. Casa Marina Key West has an interesting back story, having once been used to house the U.S. Army  during the Cuban missile crisis. Rooms start at around $300.

Sanibel and Captiva

How to get there: Breeze Airways has direct flights from MacArthur Airport to Fort Myers, rent a car for the 45-minute drive to the Sanibel Causeway.

The twin subtropical barrier islands sit about three miles off Fort Myers on Florida’s Gulf Coast. They took a major hit from Hurricane Ian in 2022, with much of the infrastructure damaged, including the causeway that joins them. "The recovery is real," said Griffin. "The islands people remember are there, open and ready to welcome you back."

Known for shell collecting and wildlife, Sanibel, Florida, is home...

Known for shell collecting and wildlife, Sanibel, Florida, is home to Sanibel Lighthouse. Credit: Visit Florida

The sister islands beckon travelers who love the quiet beaches and low-key atmosphere (they’re known for having no traffic lights). The unusual east-west orientation and an offshore shelf where thousands of mollusks congregate make this area perfect for shell collecting. Best beaches for shell collectors: Lighthouse and Bowman on Sanibel and Blind Pass and Turner Beach near the channel between the two islands.

The J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge is another popular attraction on Sanibel. With thousands of acres of mangroves, the refuge is famed for its migratory bird population, home to nearly 250 species (including the rarely sighted reddish egrets). You can drive, bike or hike the four miles of trails or take a 90-minute tram tour.

The Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum and Aquarium features exhibits with nearly 600,000 shells and 60 species of marine life.  South Seas Island Resort has multiple pools, 2.5 miles of beaches and a marina where manatees might show up. Rooms start at around $750.

Islamorada

How to get there: Fly into Miami (multiple flights on most major airlines out of LaGuardia or Kennedy)) and rent a car for the 80-mile drive on the Overseas Highway.

Made up of six islands between Key Largo and Marathon, Islamorada is known as the world’s sport fishing capital. There’s almost always some sort of tournament going on, as anglers go after sailfish, tarpon, even smaller game fish. Even if you don’t enter, it’s fun to watch competitors as they come back to the docks to weigh their catches. Go it on your own with numerous charters, check out A Fishing Guru, where a seasoned captain will take up to five passengers out for, well as they say, anything that bites.

Experience Islamorada's marine life and fishing excursions.

Experience Islamorada's marine life and fishing excursions. Credit: Getty Images

If you just want to hang out with some sea creatures, the Dolphin Life Hospital takes in marine mammals that have been stranded by anything from boat strikes to bad weather. An interactive "Explorashoreum" exhibit has touch tanks and a viewing room where visitors can observe the rescue operations. For a look at underwater marine life, take a night reef tour on a glass bottom boat, where lights will reveal creatures like eel, octopus and lobsters. Stay in a charming oceanfront cottage at Pines and Palms Resort. Rooms start at around $400.

St. George Island

How to get there: Fly into Tallahassee or Panama City (connecting flights on American and Delta from Kennedy  and LaGuardia or Southwest from MacArthur), then rent a car and drive around 75 miles to the St. George Island Bridge.

Part of Florida’s "Forgotten Coast," the tranquil 22-mile barrier island off the northern Florida panhandle is about as low key as they come — zoning laws prohibit high rises, so accommodations are in quaint inns and B&Bs. Find nine miles of undeveloped beach at Dr. Julian G. Bruce St. George Island State Park, an area that has been named among the best beaches in the nation. Follow one of the bike trails or hiking paths to see 300 species of migrating birds and the "cat face" scars on the pine trees that were once harvested for turpentine.

Climb up to the Cape St. George Lighthouse, which was reconstructed after the original collapsed into the Gulf from years of beach erosion and pounding waves. The new building opened in 2008, using many salvaged materials from the original. While on the island, you might want to visit other notable sites on the forgotten coast. The John Gorrie Museum State Park in Apalachicola honors the doctor who developed modern refrigeration — his grave is in the park. In the tiny town of Carrabelle, get a photo in what is most likely the world’s smallest police station, really a glorified phone booth. Stay in the heart of town at the Buccaneer Inn. Rooms start at around $650.

IF YOU GO 

Key West

  • Hemingway Home and Museum, 907 Whitehead St., $19, $7 ages 6-12; 305-294-1136, hemingwayhome.com.
  • Truman Little White House, 111 Front St., $24.80, $11 ages 4-12; 305-294-9911, trumanlittlewhitehouse.org.
  • Sloppy Joe’s Bar, 201 Duval St., 305-294-5717, sloppyjoes.com
  • Yankee Freedom Ferry, 100 Grinnell St., runs daily leaving at 8 a.m., $260, $220 ages 4-16, including breakfast, lunch, snorkeling, park entry and fort tour; 305-294-7009, drytortugas.com.
  • Casa Marina Key West, 15 Reynolds St., 305-296-3535, hilton.com.

Sanibel and Captiva

  • Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum and Aquarium, 3075 Sanibel Captiva Rd., Sanibel, $25, $15 ages 12-17, $10 ages 5-11; 239-395-2233, shellmuseum.org.
  • J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge, 1 Wildlife Dr., Sanibel, $10 per vehicle; 239-472-1100, fws.gov; tram tour, $22, $13 ages 3-15; 239-472-8900, tarponbayexplorers.com.
  • South Seas Island Resort, 5400 Plantation Rd., Captiva, 866-565-5089; southseas.com.

Islamorada

  • A Fishing Guru, 84001 Overseas Highway, half-day tours start at around $700 for five guests; 305-916-9130, afishing.guru.
  • Dolphin Life Hospital, 82748 Overseas Highway Mile, Islamorada, $10, backlot rescue tours at 11 a.m. and 2:30 p.m., $20, $14 ages 8-18 (not recommended for younger children); 305-453-4321, dolphilife.org.
  • Glass Bottom Boat Tours, 81576 Overseas Highway, two-hour night tours leave daily at 6 p.m., $75, $60 ages 5-17; 305-214-5277, glassbottomtour.com.
  • Pines and Palms Resort, 80401 Old Highway, 305-664-4343, pinesandpalms.com.

St. George Island

  • John Gorrie Museum State Park, 46 6th St., Apalachicola, $2, free ages 5 and under; 850-653-9347, floridastateparks.org.
  • Dr. Julian G. Bruce St. George Island State Park, 1900 E. Gulf Beach Dr., St. George Island, $6 per vehicle, $4 for single-occupant vehicle; 800-326-3521, floridastateparks.org.
  • Cape St. George Lighthouse, 2B East Gulf Beach Dr., St. George Island, open Tuesday–Sunday, entrance to museum is free, climbing fee: $7, $5 ages 7-12; 850-927-7745, stgeorgelight.org.
  • Buccaneer Inn, 160 W. Gorrie Dr., 800-847-2091, buccinn.com.