Giants wide receiver Malik Nabers fumbles during a game against the Washington...

Giants wide receiver Malik Nabers fumbles during a game against the Washington Commanders at MetLife Stadium on Thursday. Credit: Ed Murray

The Giants’ growing case of fumble-itis struck three players in Thursday’s loss to the Commanders. Malik Nabers paid the most for catching the bug.

Nabers was stripped by linebacker Frankie Luvu and the Commanders recovered. It was the first lost fumble in 28 career games for the receiver, with Nabers being another target of the “Peanut Punch” that defenders have perfected to jar the ball loose.

“You're thinking about plays that could have been a difference in the game, and that could have been one of those,” Nabers said of the fumble inside the Commanders’ 20-yard line.

It’s a problem the Giants as a whole need to fix. It was one thing when the running backs had issues, mainly Cam Skattebo's four fumbles through five games. Now it’s affecting other players and becoming a lingering issue in what has been a solid season.

Isaiah Likely recovered his own fumble Thursday. Greg Desrosiers fumbled on the final kickoff return that rookie Chandler Martin recovered in his Giants debut. The game before, it was receiver Charlie Jones dropping a punt that gave the Eagles a new set of downs.

Jones played clean on Thursday without a drop but he was waived Monday with the Giants signing former Jet Xavier Gipson from the Eagles' practice squad.

In total, the Giants’ 17 fumbles are second-most in the NFL this season behind the Packers’ 18. It is already more than they had last season with 14. According to TeamRankings, a stat-based website, the Giants are also averaging an NFL-high 1.9 fumbles per game.

The Giants have lost seven fumbles, and their rate of 0.8 lost fumbles per game is tied for 24th. Despite being in first place in the NFC East, the Giants put the ball on the ground too often and it could prove costly with the schedule getting harder starting Sunday, hosting the 7-2 Jaguars.

The good news is the running backs haven’t fumbled on a carry since Skattebo’s overtime fumble in Week 5. But 10 different Giants have fumbled at least once this season. Nabers became the sixth Giant to have a fumble recovered by the opposing team.

“It just needs to be an organizational priority,” coach John Harbaugh said in October. “You protect the football at all times if it’s your hands.”

It’s also now become an organizational problem. At their current pace, the Giants would finish with 32 total fumbles and 13 lost, the most they’ve had since 2019 (31 fumbles, 16 lost). It undermines some of the disciplined, detailed approach Harbaugh was supposed to bring.

The most fumbles by a Ravens team under Harbaugh was 28 in 2008, his first season as a head coach. Fumbling was an issue at times over his tenure but not at the rate of this year’s Giants.

Last season, the Ravens had 22 fumbles, fourth most in the NFL, and lost 12 fumbles, which was tied for the NFL’s second most. In 2024? The Ravens were better with 19 fumbles and just seven lost. In 2023, they had 23 fumbles — one fewer than the 2023 Giants — with 12 lost.

The Ravens fumbles per game those last three Harbaugh seasons? 1.3, 1.2, 1.3. That’s still way better than the Giants nearly fumbling twice a game.

Part of the reason the NFL is seeing more fumbles due to the “Peanut Punch”, a technique popularized by former Bears defensive back Charles Tillman. Instead of ripping the ball out, players are finding ways to punch it out during tackles and coaches are also teaching it as a fundamental tool.

Last season, teams averaged .99 fumbles per game, the lowest rate in the 2020s. This season? Teams are fumbling 1.24 times per game, the highest rate of this decade.

“The league is more of a punch-out league than it's ever been before, and more players are really good at it than they've ever been before,” Harbaugh said in October.

Still, that doesn’t excuse the Giants being sloppy with ball security. It will hurt them facing a Jaguars team ranked ninth in total offense and fourth in points per game. Two weeks later, the Giants face a 49ers team that’s tied for fourth in forced fumbles.

That’s why the Giants have to protect the ball better. They survived this far dropping it too much. They won’t be so lucky with five of their next six opponents being above .500.

Running backs coach Willie Taggart said earlier this season that a team’s dreams, goals and aspirations are in the football. If the Giants want to reach their goal of a playoff berth, they can’t risk losing drives due to fumbling issues.

Otherwise, the second half of the year might leave the Giants sick with regret instead of satisfied with their success.

“Just try to do better, try to be better," Nabers said, "and I’ll be better on just protecting the football.

2026 Giants (after 9 games)

17 fumbles (2nd most this season — StatMuse)

7 fumbles lost (tied for 7th most)

1.9 fumbles per game (most per TeamRankings)

0.8 fumbles lost per game (tied for 24th per TeamRankings)

2025 Giants

14 fumbles (tied for 9th fewest)

7 fumbles lost (tied for 8th fewest)

0.8 fumbles per game (tied for 6th)

0.4 fumbles lost per game (T-12th per TeamRankings)

2024 Giants

22 fumbles (tied for 8th most in the league)

10 fumbles lost (tied for 10th most)

1.3 fumbles per game (25th per TeamRankings

0.6 fumbles lost per game (T-21st per TeamRankings)

2023 Giants

24 fumbles (tied for 6th most in NFL)

7 fumbles lost (tied for 21st most)

1.4 fumbles per game (tied for 23rd per TeamRankings)

0.4 fumbles lost per game (T-10th per TeamRankings

2025 Ravens

22 fumbles (4th most in the league

12 fumbles lost (tied for 2nd most)

1.3 fumbles per game (tied for fourth most per TeamRankings)

0.7 fumbles lost per game (tied for last per TeamRankings)

2024 Ravens

19 fumbles (T-18th most)

7 fumbles lost (tied for 20th most)

1.2 fumbles per game (T-14th per TeamRankings)

0.5 fumbles lost per game (T-12th per TeamRankings)

2023 Ravens

23 fumbles (T-11th most)

12 fumbles lost (T-7th)

1.3 fumbles per game (T-19th per TeamRankings)

0.7 fumbles lost per game (26th per TeamRankings)

NFL fumble rate per game via StatMuse

1.17 per game 2020

1.2 per game in 2021

1.23 per game in 2022

1.19 per game in 2023

1.17 per game in 2024

.99 per game in 2025

1.24 per game in 2026 (ahead of Monday night's game)

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME