Islanders defenseman Matthew Schaefer reacts after scoring his first career...

Islanders defenseman Matthew Schaefer reacts after scoring his first career hat trick on an empty-net goal against the Columbus Blue Jackets in the third period of an NHL hockey game at UBS Arena on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. Credit: Kathleen Malone-Van Dyke

Matthew Schaefer lofted the puck into the empty net and raised his arms in celebration. As hats came flying out of the UBS Arena stands, the 19-year-old defenseman acknowledged the cheers and chants by skating back onto the ice for a quick lap after his first career hat trick.

“It might have a little too hard of a celly,” Schaefer said, sheepishly. “Maybe I should have been a little bit more respectful with it. But it’s awesome.”

It was a team effort as the Islanders forged their first three-game winning streak with a 5-1 win over the Eastern Conference-worst Blue Jackets. And it started with a fourth straight brilliant start from goalie Ilya Sorokin. But Schaefer’s play at his age — scratch that, for a player of any age — is so transcendent it becomes the focus.

He became just the second teenage defenseman after Hall of Famer Phil Housley to reach 30 career goals in NHL history. He now has 32, matching Hall of Famer Bryan Trottier for the Islanders’ franchise lead among all teenage skaters. And his hat trick was the first for an Islanders defenseman since Hall of Famer Denis Potvin did so in a 10-1 rout of the Maple Leafs on March 4, 1982 and the first for a teenage defenseman since Housley did it in 1983.

“We’re watching greatness,” said Mathew Barzal, who had two primary assists in his second game back in the lineup and first home game after missing all of training camp and the first 18 matches with an injured left knee. “If there was a question about the Norris [Trophy as the NHL’s top defenseman], he’s got to be right there, if not the front-runner. It’s pretty special. It’s fun to watch someone with so much enthusiasm on the ice.”

Schaefer’s 24 points (nine goals, 15 assists) in 20 games leads the Islanders. He has 32 goals and 51 assists (83 points) in 102 career games.

Against the Blue Jackets, he took a game-high nine shots in 23:23 as he consistently skated down low.

“We have arguably the best defenseman in the league, we’ve got the best goalie in the league and then you add Barzy back, it’s a nice little mix,” said defenseman Tony DeAngelo, who cruised the crease to make it 4-1 at 11:52 of the Islanders’ three-goal third period.

Sorokin stopped 28 shots as the Islanders returned from a 2-0-1 California trip that included Simon Holmstrom’s first career hat trick in Saturday’s 6-2 win in Anaheim. Sorokin improved to 9-0-3 career against the Blue Jackets (7-12-0), who have been outscored 21-8 in a five-game losing streak despite 36 saves from Cal Talbot.

Both teams turned the puck over but the Islanders mostly kept the Blue Jackets’ shots to the outside and limited traffic at the net for rebounds.

Zach Werenski, who won the Norris Trophy last season, skated around defenseman Ryan Pulock and slipped in a backhander at the crease to cut the Islanders’ lead to 2-1 at 1:12 of the third period.

But Schaefer regained a two-goal edge with his second goal, backhanding in a rebound at 7:01 of the third period. Blue Jackets interim coach Don Granato, behind the bench while Rick Bowness recovers from a medical issue, unsuccessfully challenged Casey Cizikas had interfered with Talbot.

Schaefer’s unassisted goal from the high slot at 1:34 of the second period put the Islanders ahead 2-0 and he completed his hat trick at 16:08 of the third period. He had scored two goals in a game five times previously.

So about that celebration.

“I’m not going to throw anyone under the bus but he had someone on our bench whisper in his ear that that was a good idea,” coach Pete DeBoer said with a chuckle. “I’m not sure that was all him on that. I think he was following some instructions from a guy he trusted, which was unfortunate.

“You don’t want him to lose that enthusiasm. That’s genuine. It’s fantastic and it’s what the game is about. There’s only a handful of people in the world that play it at that level. When you combine the fact that he wears those emotions on his sleeve, that’s a super thing on top of that.”

Anthony Duclair’s power-play goal at 19:02 of the first period opened the scoring, giving the Islanders a man-advantage tally in four straight games.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME