Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy throws a pass during the third...

Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy throws a pass during the third quarter against the Washington Commanders at MetLife Stadium on Nov. 12, 2026 in East Rutherford, N.J. Credit: Jim McIsaac

By any account, the J.J. McCarthy experiment has been a success so far. The Giants have pumped new life into his career, and he has exceeded expectations as the team’s third quarterback this season.

McCarthy began the season demoted and discarded as the Vikings’ third-string quarterback, but now is when he’ll prove if that trade pays off.

Five of the Giants’ next six opponents have winning records, starting with the Jaguars on Sunday. If they’re going to survive that slate, then John Harbaugh needs to lean more on McCarthy and trust his arm to win games and not be as conservative as they were last Thursday losing to the Commanders.

“I think he's proven that he's capable of winning games and making the plays and I probably feel more strongly about that now than ever,” Harbaugh said. “It was his third game, I think, maybe now starting. So we're definitely in the process of growing that confidence for sure.”

Before that, Harbaugh said the play calls could have been different after the Giants got two fourth-quarter interceptions. The offense had three straight runs after each turnover and neither drive gained a first down.

On a third-and-1 play during the first drive, Jameis Winston’s quarterback sneak failed. On third-and-3 the next drive, McCarthy ran outside to the left and lost two yards. Those plays stalled drives and gave the Commanders enough time to rally for a win.

Harbaugh defended the play-calling and said the Giants didn’t play scared or safe. The outcome, however, proved that not trusting McCarthy’s arm -- or Cam Skattebo on third-and-short -- burned them. McCarthy's last pass before that drive was a 66-yard touchdown to Isaiah Likely on third down, a play Harbaugh said was as good as any in the NFL this season.

“We thought we could get it with the runs,” Harbaugh said of the third-down attempts. “Also keep the clock running and make them burn the timeouts. We thought we could do both. But looking back on it, I think a good pass there might've been good too.”

Those mistakes can’t happen again. It will cost them against the Jaguars, Colts, 49ers and Seahawks, the Giants’ next four foes. They turned to J.J. McCarthy for a reason. Let him rip it until he gives reason not to.

Since that fourth quarter against the Saints in Week 6, he’s thrown 17 completions of at least 20 yards, tied for fourth most in that span. In two of his three starts, he’s set career highs in passing yards.

He’s completed 63.5% of his passes, a huge jump from last season. With the Vikings, McCarthy’s 57.6% completion percentage ranked near the NFL’s worst among quarterbacks that qualified among league leaders in passing.

McCarthy’s yards per attempt is 8.8, well above the league average, which is 7.1. He has just one turnover, the interception on his final pass last Thursday. It’s another improvement from someone who led the league in interception percentage last season.

The sample size is still small, but it's enough to say McCarthy has earned more leeway, especially since the team can’t trust the run game to keep the offense balanced. Letting him throw shows the team’s faith in his play so far.

“Just being in the league for a little over two years now, just seeing defenses that I’ve seen before and running concepts I’ve run before, everything just seems like it’s slowing down for me,” McCarthy said. “So just being able to keep stacking and keep growing 1% every single day, I’m just so blessed to be in this offense.”

Now the flip side. He hasn’t been perfect. McCarthy had just 92 passing yards on 19 attempts in the first half last Thursday. His numbers weren’t great against the Eagles (12-for-19, 127 yards) and the offense struggled as a result.

While the Giants have found the end zone under McCarthy’s watch, he has just two touchdown passes. The greatest concern is he has been sacked 10 times since that Saints game, a sack percentage of 8.77%.

Winston’s sack percentage is 8.79% and that’s the seventh-highest among qualified quarterbacks, according to Pro-Football Reference.

That’s definitely an issue, especially since McCarthy injured his hip against the Eagles. It shouldn’t prohibit the Giants from trusting him more.

"I just feel really good in terms of my preparation going into every week,” McCarthy said. "They are very detailed in terms of what they want from me, what the intent is every single play. There is no gray area going into each play and I just really appreciate the heck out of that.”

It’s why the Giants should put more on McCarthy’s shoulders. If they want a fighting chance against a difficult schedule, let it rise or fall on his arm.

Subscribe

Unlimited Digital AccessOnly 25¢for 6 months

SUBSCRIBESALE ENDS SOON | CANCEL ANYTIME